MELVIN FRANCISCO MATHEWS BERMUDEZ, D.P.M.

NPI 1831297530, individual, Manati, PR, Podiatrist

Evidence tier

documented action, then payment

Listed on the Medicare revocation list since January 22, 2020.
Medicaid still paid claims in 32 later months, $165,501 in total.

score 95 of 100, rank 119, $166K at stake

Public list actions

Medicare revocation effective January 22, 2020, barred from re-enrolling until January 22, 2030

424.535(a)(9) failure to report and 424.535(a)(3) felonies and 424.535(a)(2) provider or supplier conduct (exclusion), Practitioner - Podiatry, PR

OIG exclusion September 20, 2022 under section 1128a1

Ind- Lic HC Serv Pro, Podiatry, Vega Alta, PR

Paid after the action

Months in which Medicaid paid claims for this provider after a public action that should have triggered a screening check. This is a record of payments, not a determination that they were improper.

list	identity check	action date	window closed	months paid after	first	last	paid after	12 months before
Medicare revocation list 424.535(a)(9) failure to report and 424.535(a)(3) felonies and 424.535(a)(2) provider or supplier conduct (exclusion)	Exact NPI, name verified	Jan 22, 2020	Jan 22, 2030	32	Feb 2020	Sep 2022	$166K	$33K

National provider registry

From the CMS NPPES Registry, refreshed daily.

Name	MELVIN FRANCISCO MATHEWS BERMUDEZ, D.P.M.
Type	Individual
Status	Active
NPI issued	September 20, 2006, last updated April 24, 2012
Practice location	CALLE ELLIOT VELEZ J-15, URB. ATENAS, Manati, PR 00674-4616, 787-854-6429
Specialties	Podiatrist (213E00000X, primary, license 102 PR)

Procedures billed

The specific codes behind the dollars. Medicaid figures come from T-MSIS (2018 to 2024) and are compared with every other provider billing the same code; Medicare figures come from the 2024 physician and supplier file and compare this provider's submitted charge with what Medicare allowed, against the usual ratio for that code.

Medicaid, largest codes

code	what it is	paid	share	per patient-month	typical	rank among providers
20550	Injection into tendon or ligament	$65K	26%	$53	$43 (top 5% from $195)	68th percentile
99213	Established patient office or other outpatient visit with low level od decision making, if using time, 20 minutes or more	$51K	20%	$53	$44 (top 5% from $110)	63rd percentile
99203	New patient office or other outpatient visit with low level of medical decision making, if using time, 30 minutes or more	$32K	13%	$71	$67 (top 5% from $121)	57th percentile
11750	Permanent removal fingernail or toenail	$24K	10%	$75	$118 (top 5% from $186)	18th percentile
99214	Established patient office or other outpatient visit with moderate level of decision making, if using time, 30 minutes or more	$22K	9%	$22	$60 (top 5% from $133)	11th percentile
11730	Simple separation of fingernail or toenail from nail bed, first nail	$20K	8%	$71	$23 (top 5% from $93)	90th percentile
99204	New patient office or other outpatient visit with moderate level of medical decision making, if using time, 45 minutes or more	$16K	6%	$25	$95 (top 5% from $171)	5th percentile
10140	Drainage of blood or fluid accumulation	$15K	6%	$108		too few months to rank

In this area

81 providers in PR carry an indicator in the public record, with $52.6M at stake between them. The most common is more hours than a day holds, on 71 of them, followed by part of a provider network on 5. 5 are tier 1: documented action, then payment.

tier	provider	at stake	why
1	PHYSICIAN H.M.O. INC. San Juan, PR, ranked 158	$81K	Adjudicated (pleaded guilty) per a Department of Justice release dated July 17, 2025. Medicaid paid $81,097 in the last 12 observed months.
1	DIANA GALLARDO Caguas, PR, ranked 321	$5K	Listed on the OIG exclusion list and the Medicare revocation list since July 9, 2021. Medicaid still paid claims in 8 later months, $5,215 in total.
1	VILLALBA MEDICAL TRANSPORT LLC Juana Diaz, PR, ranked 401	$909	Listed on the Medicare revocation list since November 2, 2023. Medicaid still paid claims in 1 later month, $909 in total.
1	PHYSICIAN HMO INC. San Juan, PR, ranked 408	$680	Adjudicated (pleaded guilty) per a Department of Justice release dated July 17, 2025. Medicaid paid $680 in the last 12 observed months.
1	PHYSICIAN HMO INC. Rio Piedras, PR, ranked 460	$0	Adjudicated (pleaded guilty) per a Department of Justice release dated July 17, 2025. No Medicaid payments in the last 12 observed months.
2	YAMIR GARCIA SEGARRA Caguas, PR, ranked 696	$1.9M	Billed more hands-on hours than a day holds in 3 months, peaking at 22.2 hours per day across 3 billing organizations. Medicaid dollars per patient on code 92526 ($630 per patient-month) sit in the top 5% of every provider billing that code.
3	CMS HOME CARE NORTE, LLC Hatillo, PR, ranked 3502	$0	Part of provider network D1-00068, ranked 68 nationally.
3	CMS HOME CARE OESTE, LLC. Mayaguez, PR, ranked 3559	$0	Part of provider network D1-00068, ranked 68 nationally.

All 81 in PR

Recent enforcement in PR

All releases

Department of Justice and HHS-OIG releases for this state, newest first. Each opens in a new tab.

DOJIndictedJun 23, 2026

2026 National Health Care Fraud Takedown

Four defendants were charged in two schemes, one involving the advertising, sale, and distribution of Semaglutide, Mounjaro, steroids, and Tirzepatide that defendants were not authorized to possess and distribute, and the other involving performing dental procedures on patients without a valid dental license and misbranding of devices.

DOJCivil settlementJun 4, 2026

Puerto Rico Pharmacies Agree to Pay $4.6 Million to Federal Authorities in Medicare and Medicaid Fraud Cases

Four pharmacies and their owners agreed to pay $4.6 million to resolve allegations that between January 2021 and January 2024 they billed Medicare and Medicaid for diverted prescriptions sold to patients that had been misrepresented as properly sourced despite unverifiable origins.

DOJPleaded guiltyJul 17, 2025

Physician Assistant who Pretended to be a Licensed Physician Pleads Guilty to Making False Statements to an Agency of the United States

Villalobos-Meléndez, a licensed physician assistant who was never licensed to practice medicine, forged medical license and USMLE documents, worked as a physician in a hospital internship program, and submitted false license information on a CMS-855I form seeking enrollment as a Medicare physician provider with benefits reassigned to Physician HMO.

DOJCivil settlementDec 23, 2024

MMM Holdings, LLC Agrees to Pay 15.2 Million Dollars to Resolve Allegations that it Violated the False Claims Act and Anti-Kickback Statute

MMM Holdings distributed gift cards to administrative assistants of providers to induce the referral, recommendation, or arrangement for enrollment of thousands of Medicare beneficiaries in an MMM Medicare Advantage plan and submitted or caused claims for payment to Medicare.

DOJIndictedSep 25, 2024

27 Individuals Indicted for Buying and Selling Wholesale Quantities of Misbranded and Diverted Prescription Drugs Resold to the Public Through Retail Pharmacies in Puerto Rico

Defendants engaged in unlicensed wholesale distribution of misbranded and diverted prescription drugs sold to pharmacy owners and employees who resold them to customers and billed health care benefit plans as if the drugs were authentic and obtained through licensed distribution channels.

Referral packet

The packet is a draft for a reviewer. It reads every public record behind this case, states what the records show with a citation for each finding, names the regulation each finding relates to, and lists the ordinary explanations to rule out first. It never asserts intent.

Ask this case

Answers come only from the evidence tables, and every sentence cites the record it used.